ICT for Development

Where information and communication technologies are central to social and economic development

ICT for Development| Approaches| Tools| Issues| Regions/Countries| MDGs| Polls / Discussions

Average Rating: no ratings submitted

Between Exposé and Libel: Online Activity and the Lack of Institutional Accountability

Author

Claire Wren

One World Trust

Publication Date

July 2007

Summary

This article on global internet and accountability discusses the increasing audience for individual voices finding avenues for online expression through blogs, websites such as YouTube, and online editorials. The author points out that these voices sometimes progress from commenting on the news to setting the news agenda because they are speaking outside of an institutional framework.

 

The example given is that of remarks which caused a United States (US) Senator to resign his leadership position due to remarks of a racist nature to which bloggers brought consistent web-based attention. A second example is the impact of videos posted on YouTube about the US presidential election, as well as the emergence of "attack ads" online unaffiliated with the parties campaigning. A third example is a "gripe site" for gathering complaints against a multinational oil company.

 

The internal accountability of traditional media overseen by editors is not present as an institutional framework for independent online bloggers. As stated here, even United Kingdom (UK) libel laws are "effectively circumvented" because financial penalties leveraged against assets do not work where there are no significant assets.

 

"To address the absence of accountability mechanisms and concomitant concern that there is power without responsibility, there have been some attempts to develop self-regulating Codes of Conduct. One of the most high profile is that started by Jimmy Wales, founder of Wikipedia, and Tim O’Reilly, who coined the term 'Web 2.0'." The O'Reilly-Wales collaboration has produced a modular code and includes postings of a number of other codes. According to the author, this has proved controversial. With little for bloggers to lose, the article speculates that social norms and pressures may be ineffective. The casual and conversational nature of the internet challenges both social norms and accountability. The borderless nature of the internet presents an accountability enforcement challenge; the author suggests a need to address the potential of the imbalance between the power of online publication and the lack of accountability.


Contact

Claire Wren

Gina Bergh
One World Trust

3 Whitehall Court

London
SW1A 2EL
Great Britain & Northern Ireland (UK)
Tel: 44 0 20 7766 3467
Fax: 44 0 20 7839 7718

Source

One World Trust website on December 21 2007.


Placed on the Communication Initiative site December 21 2007
Last Updated January 14 2008

How useful did you find this page to your work?

1 - not useful    5 - very useful

Feel free to leave us comments

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Help Seed The CI Network

Login / Register

Subscribe to The Drum Beat, Contribute to Forums, Get Poll Results etc
New to CI? » Start here

Development Classifieds

Local Language Materials?

How important are efforts to translate internet materials into local languages?