Democracy and Governance

Where communication and media are central to Democracy and Governance

DEMOCRACY AND GOVERNANCE| Approaches| Tools| Issues| Regions/Countries| MDGs| Polls / Discussions

Average Rating: 4.5 out of 5 (2 ratings submitted)

Development Pornography: Images of the Global South

Author

Danielle Goldfinger

Spring 2006

Summary

Canadian activist Danielle Goldfinger here explores development pornography, or the use of shocking, graphic images of people in the global South who are living poverty as part of campaigns by non-governmental organisations (NGOs) to spur the general public into donating money. Despite these NGOs' good intentions, Goldfinger argues, the images can have "disastrous consequences". In this 2-page opinion piece, she illustrates these consequences, explores new trends in ethical marketing, and explains what strategies can be undertaken to ensure that NGOs use more responsible communications plans to access funding.

Consequences of "development pornography" include:

  • Creation and solidification of stereotypes, such as that of the entire continent of Africa being rife with poverty, disease, and malnourishment.
  • Dehumanisation: Individuals depicted in the images have their individual stories stripped away; they become simplified representations of many others from varied communities, cities, countries.
  • Masking of the root causes of poverty, and diversion of attention from issues of justice and basic human rights toward values of charity and pity - with an associated reinforcement of the belief that the North is superior - full of generous givers who can "cure" poverty through aid - and that the South is helpless and powerless.

Observation of these consequences has spurred a debate on the ethics of marketing in the development community, leading organisations such as British Overseas NGO Development (BOND) to argue that - while it is not necessary to stop showing realistic but graphic images of poverty - political and social context must be included to promote better understanding of the South. This debate has, in turn, motivated various efforts to reform marketing approaches, such as the conferences hosted by a coalition called the Canadian Council for International Cooperation (CCIC) since 2001. The 2004 conference revealed that many NGOs are shifting their messaging to link fundraising with education and advocacy and to include the broader context of images.

The author elaborates on this strategy by explaining that NGOs should not only ask for donations, but should inform individuals about the connection between unfair trade laws, debt, and poverty - also encouraging them to get actively involved in lobbying to fight for justice rather than simply sending money.

A second core strategy for preventing development pornography, according to Goldfinger, is the development of codes that foster ethical practices, such as CCIC's Code of Ethics (which prescribes truth and accurate marketing to the public), or codes of conduct that NGOs must follow in their fundraising and advocacy tactics in order to receive government funds.


Contact

Danielle Goldfinger
Toronto, Canada
danielle.goldfinger@gmail.com

Placed on the Communication Initiative site September 25 2006
Last Updated September 26 2006

How useful did you find this page to your work?

1 - not useful    5 - very useful

Feel free to leave us comments

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Help Seed The CI Network

Login / Register

Subscribe to The Drum Beat, Contribute to Forums, Get Poll Results etc
New to CI? » Start here

Development Classifieds

Free and Plural Media

What is your answer to James Deane's blog question: "Is a free and plural media more important than elections in securing democratic development?"